Assignments and Sub-Leases
Privity of Estate:
Privity of Contract:
Assignments and subleases are terms for situations in which a tenant in possession of property transfers his or her right to possess that property to a third party. If the lessee transfers his or her entire remaining interest in the tenancy, then the transfer is known as an assignment. If the lessee transfers only part of his or her interest, then the transfer is known as a sublease. For example:
- Barney leases Rubbleacre from Fred for two years, beginning January 1, 2013 and ending on December 31, 2014 at the rental price of $1,000 per month. On January 1, 2014, with one year remaining on the lease, Barney and Kazoo agree that Kazoo will occupy the land for the remainder of the lease, and that Kazoo will pay the $1,000 per month rent to Fred. In this case, Barney has “assigned” his lease to Kazoo.
- Barney leases Rubbleacre from Fred for two years, beginning January 1, 2013 and ending on December 31, 2014 at the rental price of $1,000 per month. On January 1, 2014, with one year remaining on the lease, Barney and Kazoo agree that Kazoo will occupy the land for the next six months and pay the rent for those months. At the end of six months, Barney will move back onto the land and finish out the remainder of the lease. In this case because Barney and Kazoo have agreed that Kazoo will assume less than the full remainder of the lease, Barney has “sublet” part of his interest in Rubbleacre to Kazoo.
See McClain Airlines, Inc. v. Republic Airlines, Inc., 1991 U.S. App. LEXIS 18047 (1991).
As a general principle, both assignments and subleases are allowed, and so any tenant can assign his or her lease to a third party or sublease his or her interest in the property to a third party at any time. However, as a practical matter, many lease agreements specifically prohibit assignments or subleases. Of course, any agreement between landlord and tenant that prohibits assignments or subleases is fully binding and enforceable.
The key issue to be discussed, then, is what affect the transfer of interest has on all the involved parties. Since there are several parties involved in these transactions, we will start by defining the parties. In an assignment, there is the landlord/ lessor (the property owner), the tenant/ assignor (the person who leased it from the landlord and then assigned his or her interest to a third party) and the assignee (the person who received the assignment). In a sublease, there is the landlord/ lessor, the tenant/ sublessor (the party who leased the property from the landlord but is now subleasing the property to a third party), and the sublessee.
As a further necessary introduction, there are two forms of relationship between every landlord and tenant. There is a contractual relationship that took effect and exists by virtue of the lease agreement itself. That relationship is known as “privity of contract”. In addition, there is a property ownership relationship, by virtue of their sharing of the ownership of the property. That relationship is known as “privity of estate”. “Privity of estate” exists between two parties when those two parties have successive ownerships in the same property (i.e., one holds a present interest while the other holds a future interest or they both hold future interests, one after another).
An assignment is a full transfer of the lease between the tenant and the assignee. Therefore, since the tenant no longer has any ownership interest in the property, there is no longer any relationship between the landlord and the tenant as far as the property ownership is concerned. Therefore, there is no longer “privity of estate” between the landlord and the tenant. On the other hand, there now is privity of estate between the landlord and the assignee. This is because the assignee now owns the present interest in the property. This present interest will end only at the end of the lease when it will go back to the landlord. Since the landlord’s right to possession is now successive to the possession of the assignee, the landlord and assignee are in privity of estate.
Privity of contract, on the other hand, still exists between the landlord and the tenant. This is because the original contract that existed between the landlord and the tenant is still fully valid even after the assignment. In other words, the landlord does not give up his or her right to enforce the lease agreement with the tenant just because the tenant transfers his or her interest to the third party. There is no privity of contract, of course, between the landlord and the assignee because those two parties never agreed to anything between themselves. For example:
Ethel owns Blackacre. She leases Blackacre to Lucy for 5 years. During year 2, Lucy assigns her interest in Blackacre to Ricky. Ethel is in privity of estate with Ricky and not Lucy and in privity of contract with Lucy and not Ricky. Also note that Lucy and Ricky are in privity of contract (because they made an agreement with each other), but not in privity of estate (Lucy has no possession interest in Blackacre, and so she does not have an interest that either follows or is followed by Ricky’s interest).
The sublease is only a partial transfer of interest from the tenant to the sublessee. The tenant is transferring part of his or her interest in time to the sublessee. Therefore, there is no privity of contract or privity of estate between the landlord and the sublessee in a sublease. The reason that there is no privity of estate between the landlord and the sublessee is that the landlord’s right to possession of the property does not follow the sublessee’s right to possession. Instead, it still follows the tenant’s right of possession. The landlord is, however, still in both privity of estate and privity of contract with the tenant. Privity of contract is still applicable for the same reason as with the assignment (the landlord and the tenant agreed on the terms of the original lease). In addition, there is privity of estate between the landlord and the tenant because the right to possession of the landlord still follows the right of possession of the tenant. For example:
Ethel owns Blackacre. She leases Blackacre to Lucy for 5 years. During year 2, Lucy subleases Blackacre to Ricky for one year. Ethel is not in privity of estate or privity of contract with Ricky because she did not make an agreement with Ricky and because her interest in possession of Blackacre does not follow Ricky’s (it follows the end of Lucy’s five year lease). On the other hand, Ethel and Lucy are in both privity of contract (because their agreement is still valid) and privity of estate (because Ethel’s interest follows the end of Lucy’s lease). Note that Lucy and Ricky are in both privity of estate and privity of contract. They are in privity of contract because they made an agreement with each other. They are in privity of estate because Lucy’s interest (in the remainder of her lease) follows Ricky’s interest (Lucy will get Blackacre at the end of Ricky’s one year sublease).
The ramifications of who is in privity of what with whom can be crystalized in a few rules:
- A party collecting rent (landlord from the tenant or tenant from assignee or sublessee) can collect rent from someone with whom he or she is in privity of contract or privity of estate.
- A party looking to enforce obligations of the landlord can only enforce those obligations against a party with whom he or she is in privity of estate.
- The contractual terms of the lease itself can only be enforced against a party with whom the party seeking to enforce the terms is in privity of contract.
1. Ethel owns Blackacre. She leases Blackacre to Lucy for 5 years. During year 2, Lucy assigns her interest in Blackacre to Ricky.
- Ethel may collect rent from Ricky or Lucy.
- Lucy may not collect rent from Ricky.
- Ricky may enforce landlords’ obligations against Ethel, but not against Lucy. Lucy may not enforce landlords’ obligations against Ethel.
2. Ethel owns Blackacre. She leases Blackacre to Lucy for 5 years. During year 2, Lucy subleases Blackacre to Ricky for one year.
- Ethel may collect rent from Lucy, only, not Ricky.
- Lucy may collect rent from Ricky.
- Ricky may enforce landlords’ obligations against Lucy, but not against Ethel.
- Lucy may enforce landlords’ obligations against Ethel.
Do you need help with with essay, research paper, homework or even dissertation?
Visit our website Where Can I Find Someone to Write My College Paper - https://goo.gl/HKbmHS (assignmenthelp24.com)
=================>>>GET ASSIGNMENT HELP<<<=================
=================>>>GET ASSIGNMENT HELP<<<=================
=================>>>GET ASSIGNMENT HELP<<<=================
dxtr illustration essay
comic essay topics
iisd holiday assignment class 1
article 2314 code civil explication essay
litterbugs essay contest
foxglove manor deed of assignment
roger scruton why beauty matters essay definition
the domain and range of a function homework online
frederick douglass narrative of the life summary essay
northern illinois university admissions essay
arcadia cover letter
mba essays india
replace in shell variable assignment
which person is customarily used in a research paper
jacques ranciere bibliography apa
natalie dessay haendel
essay on old age homes wikipedia dictionary
example of thesis statement for essays
essay examples for Where Can I Find Someone to Write My College Paper middle school
changing face of terrorism essay topics
sample uva supplement essays
breast cancer research paper thesis samples
en1320 research paper
global warming essay titles on pride
example of nursing student cover letter
writing descriptive essay place
ponnala lakshmaiah mla bibliography
gmfrs critical thinking
altpreussische bibliography de mariama ba
free school homework passes
int213 assignment 1 skeletal system
picnic with my family essay examples
latest research papers in plant biotechnology course
ceramium rubrum classification essay
animal cruelty essay conclusion maker
essays on wisdom comes with age
a2 english literature coursework bookshelves
dr essay albany ny
your favourite food essay samples
pgce personal statement secondary physical education
appendix in apa 6 format bibliography
acknowledgement sample for student assignment sheets
ignou pgdt assignment 2011 super
dean s list cornell ilr essay
topics on psychology for a research paper
list of topics for compare and contrast essay example
street crime in pakistan essay in english
philosophy essay prompts for common
abstracts for research papers example
the person i admire the most essay mother
ltc broadening assignments
humanness essay topics
class participation essays
organizational method for process analysis essay
personal essay for medical school
essay topics for persuasion by jane austen
essays on edward lear and nonsense
an artists personal statement ao3 down
best english words for essays
help me with my physical science homework
human genetic engineering essays
good introduction paragraph for a descriptive essay
Where Can I Find Someone to Write My College Paper preschool homework printable
essay about sea in tamil
short essay about the hunger games
sample cover letter for visa application germany
2cb rave experience essay
ipinagbabawal na gamot essay format
quality of friends essay
easy books to write essays on
apple monopoly research paper
good thesis statement comparison essay
peconic bay medical center residency personal statement
how do i find sources for a research paper
overpopulation a problem essay
persuasive essay topics about social media
essay about 2010 world cup
radar source evaluation assignment
ignou ms-03 solved assignment 2014 impala
gcse t - totals maths coursework
cornell graduate school dissertation
cover letter for second job
i graded your homework it was delicious in persian
literary analysis essay on pride and prejudice soundtrack
chateau de chaugy bessay akron
inner city youth violence essay
essay topics for ib exam 2012
animal testing argumentative essay conclusion
tennessee williams free essays
new product strategy at kellogg case study
life is like a rainbow essay
5rwm assignment submission
overcoming bias to learn about controversial topics for essays
comment aborder un sujet de dissertation
wssu admissions essay editing
reformation essay conclusion example
cal state admission essay prompt
georgetown short Where Can I Find Someone to Write My College Paper essay word limit
Where Can I Find Someone to Write My College Paper bibtex example revtex bibliography
true love Where Can I Find Someone to Write My College Paper wait essay about myself
little women essay questions
in an ideal world essay contest
essay background statement
boston college essay college confidential
how to write a good introduction for persuasive essays
thesis compare contrast research paper
research paper works cited example internet
book reference for bibliography
personal essay for job application
essay on making school education stress free
missing values are not allowed in subscripted assignments of data frames
bcsl 013 solved assignment 2014-15 nba
one love song analysis essay
chi square research paper
sample outline for an essay mla
nanako homework persona 4 dancing
ralf zeichner dissertation outline
us senate committee assignments 2013 calendar
art show assignment
masters essay for education
sasbadi spm essay sample
computer assignment for high school students
choosing career path essay
decrescendo music definition essay
french revolution 1789 essays
eco-14 solved assignment 2012-13 champions
cover letter for bill of quantities construction
paul revere biography essay requirements
list of tables and figures dissertation titles
dissertation format sample
whale rider film review essay rubric
essay for texas a&m admission requirements top 25%
objective cover letter examples
best english essay writing
private university vs public university essay writing
puneet rajkumar film names in essays
meat vs vegetarian diet term paper
act essay tips and tricks
research paper on cancer therapy
ann d ballinger scholarship essays
student affairs cover letter
essay effect of war
examples of synopsis for dissertations abstracts
parametric eigenstructure assignment of lease